Is State Tax Nexus Calculated on an Entity Level?

Someone on Reddit asked whether state tax nexus is calculated on an entity level: if a company had several subsidiaries, would each be afforded a different nexus calculation, so that (in theory) the company could sell as much as it wanted by creating new entities, even if that approach is impracticable. Yes. State tax nexus is generally calculated at the entity level, meaning each business entity (e.g., each subsidiary) is evaluated independently for its connection to a state based on its own activities, physical presence, and (for sales tax) economic nexus. That does not mean creating multiple entities to avoid nexus is safe or effective: tax authorities may treat related entities as a single economic unit or recharacterize the structure, so the strategy can be complex and may not deliver the intended result.

Bottom line: Yes. State tax nexus is generally calculated on an entity level; each subsidiary or business entity is assessed individually for whether it has nexus in a particular state based on its own physical presence, sales, and activities. Creating multiple entities solely to avoid nexus can be complex and may not provide the intended tax benefits, particularly if states or tax authorities view the entities as part of a single economic unit or recharacterize the arrangement. Consult a tax professional familiar with multi-entity structures and state nexus rules for your situation.

Question from Reddit

Is state tax nexus calculated on an entity level?

Unsolved

I know it's ultimately not a practical solution but if a company were to have several subsidiaries would each be afforded a different nexus calculation thus allowing a company to sell as much as they want so long as they albeit impractically create new entities?

Source: Reddit

Analysis

The user is asking whether state tax nexus is determined per entity, so that subsidiaries are each evaluated separately for nexus (and thus, in theory, a parent could have many subsidiaries each staying below a state's nexus threshold). Nexus is the level of connection a business must have with a state for that state to impose tax obligations. The question is whether that connection is measured entity by entity or whether states can aggregate or look through related entities. Nexus is typically determined at the entity level: each business entity is evaluated independently based on its own physical presence, sales, and activities in the state. Subsidiaries can therefore have different nexus outcomes depending on their own operations and presence. That said, creating multiple entities mainly to avoid nexus is risky: states and tax authorities may aggregate related entities or apply substance-over-form or step-transaction principles, so the strategy may not work and can create compliance and audit risk.

Answer

Yes. State tax nexus is generally calculated on an entity level.

Entity-level evaluation

Each business entity (e.g., a subsidiary, LLC, or corporation) is evaluated independently for whether it has nexus in a particular state. Factors include physical presence (office, employees, property in the state), economic nexus (e.g., sales or transaction thresholds into the state), and other business activities as defined by that state.
Subsidiaries can have different nexus results: one subsidiary may have nexus in a state (e.g., employees or sales there) while another has none (no presence and sales below that state's economic nexus threshold). So in principle, each entity gets its own nexus calculation based on its activities and presence.

Why creating entities to avoid nexus is risky

Creating multiple entities primarily to avoid or minimize nexus (e.g., spinning up a new subsidiary whenever one approaches a state's threshold) is not a reliable or practical strategy. States and tax authorities may:
- Aggregate or attribute the activities or sales of related entities (e.g., parent and subsidiaries) and treat them as a single economic unit for nexus purposes.
- Apply substance-over-form or step-transaction doctrines to recharacterize the structure, so that the form (separate entities) is disregarded and nexus is determined as if there were one taxpayer.
So even though nexus is calculated at the entity level, structuring many entities mainly to stay under thresholds can be complex, challenged on audit, and may not produce the intended tax outcome. Consult a tax professional familiar with multi-entity structures and state nexus rules before relying on such a structure.

Summary

Nexus = generally entity-level; each subsidiary is assessed on its own presence and activities.
Using multiple entities to avoid nexus = risky; states may aggregate or look through, so the strategy may fail and create exposure.

Applicable Sections

Federal / IRS

Nexus for state income and sales tax is governed by state law, not a single federal rule. The IRS does not define nexus for state purposes. States typically assess nexus at the entity level, with each business evaluated based on its own physical presence and operations in the state.

State

State nexus rules vary by jurisdiction. Each entity's nexus is generally determined based on its specific activities and connections to the state; subsidiaries may be evaluated separately. Some states have rules or guidance on related entities, aggregation, or attribution that can affect when multiple entities are treated as one for nexus. Check each state's tax authority or a state and local tax (SALT) professional for your structure.

Practical Notes

Nexus is typically entity-level: each subsidiary (or entity) is evaluated on its own presence and activities.
Creating many entities mainly to avoid nexus is complex and may not achieve the intended result; states may aggregate related entities or apply substance-over-form.
Understand nexus rules in each state where you do business and how they apply to related or multi-entity structures; rules vary by state.
Margen can help you model business income and tax; for nexus and multi-entity planning, consult a tax professional or SALT specialist.

Limitations

This answer does not cover every state's nexus rules, aggregation or attribution rules for related entities, or local taxes. State law and agency positions vary and change. For your multi-entity structure and each state you operate in, consult a tax professional familiar with state nexus and multi-entity tax. You can use Margen for income and tax modeling; for nexus and structure, rely on state guidance or a SALT pro.

Are you experiencing a similar problem?

Try Margen to work through resolutions and file your taxes correctly.

Try Margen

← Back to all articles

Is State Tax Nexus Calculated on an Entity Level? (Reddit Q&A)